Saber Forum

General Chat => Videos => Topic started by: Darth Vigorous on June 16, 2017, 09:51:16 AM



Title: Fan Film - Whatever happened to Mace Windu?
Post by: Darth Vigorous on June 16, 2017, 09:51:16 AM
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UAT7DkQO5q0 (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UAT7DkQO5q0)


Title: Re: Fan Film - Whatever happened to Mace Windu?
Post by: Therion Jinn on June 16, 2017, 04:57:02 PM
I'm afraid I cannot agree with your interpretation of these events.
While Master Windu may, indeed, have survived his betrayal at the hands of Skywalker, he was the battlemaster of the Jedi Order.

I am fairly certain that Lord Vader was never his equal in combat.

It was only with Palpatine there as well that Windu was initially defeated.

The video was well done. I will give credit for that


Title: Re: Fan Film - Whatever happened to Mace Windu?
Post by: Darth Vigorous on June 21, 2017, 03:35:13 PM
I wasn't debating wether or not Mace survived, I just thought this was a cool fan film based on the idea of IF he survived.


Title: Re: Fan Film - Whatever happened to Mace Windu?
Post by: Master Nero Attoru on June 22, 2017, 03:45:15 PM
I'm afraid I cannot agree with your interpretation of these events.
While Master Windu may, indeed, have survived his betrayal at the hands of Skywalker, he was the battlemaster of the Jedi Order.

I am fairly certain that Lord Vader was never his equal in combat.

It was only with Palpatine there as well that Windu was initially defeated.

The video was well done. I will give credit for that

FYI, he wasn't the Battlemaster, although he was one of the most skilled swordsmen of the Order.  The title of Battlemaster belonged to Cin Drallig, at the time.  IMO, Windu was the superior swordsman, but Drallig was known as an excellent teacher.

Just a little correction ;)


Title: Re: Fan Film - Whatever happened to Mace Windu?
Post by: Therion Jinn on June 23, 2017, 02:52:09 AM
FYI, he wasn't the Battlemaster, although he was one of the most skilled swordsmen of the Order.  The title of Battlemaster belonged to Cin Drallig, at the time.  IMO, Windu was the superior swordsman, but Drallig was known as an excellent teacher.

Just a little correction ;)
I stand corrected on the Battlemaster point


Title: Re: Fan Film - Whatever happened to Mace Windu?
Post by: Master Nero Attoru on June 23, 2017, 01:19:28 PM
At any rate, this was quite entertaining!  Choreography wasn't good, but the banter and acting was surprisingly enjoyable.  Good find!