From your description, it sounds as tough you've knocked an LED die off the star - meaning that, unless you are quite adept at soldering very fine parts, yes it's pooched.
I fully concur with tx_tuff though; a pic or two would certainly help.
For future reference, don't do that...lol The LED dies are kind of fragile, and susceptible to oils and acids from your fingers anyways. I wear gloves whenever I handle one, and treat it like a snowflake...lol
I truly hope that's not the case DarthSithis19. It does sound like it though.