|
Title: Should I post the "Mace Windu" font I made? Ethical revision, please help Post by: CyberKyber on May 16, 2017, 05:37:06 PM Hey all! So, I have a bit of a dilemma. I just spent the better part of this day finishing up a very special (and hilarious) font that I needed to have. Now, I'd love to post it, but here's the deal:
First off, it's a font which is just Samuel L. Jackson (or Mace Windu if you prefer XD) saying "MotherF*****" over and over. It's got custom everything, custom ignition, power off, lockup, swings, clashes, boots (and a Mace Windu "This party's over" boot sound), mixing saber effects with his actual voice, not just his voice. For the lightsaber effects, I believed I used "Lightsaber 3" by Aldar Beedo (props to you, all your fonts are amazing and also make up for great bases). Now, two things about this font: 1) This is a font with a lot of profanity, well, 100% profanity actually XD Only swearing (which is fine by me, but I don't want to offend anyone either...). and most important of all: 2) It wasn't my idea. I believe the idea is originally from Shameem Moshrefzadeh, quite a big youtuber, saber installer and font creator (which he posts on saber font). I love his work, and have actually bought a few of his fonts (and will never give them away or use them as bases, obviously XD). The thing is, he showed he created a very similar font (essentially the same, just Samuel L. Jackson saying that word over and over) but with no swing or clash sounds. I think he made that font for personal use only because he has not posted it anywhere, so I decided to make it myself from zero. So that's the big ethical doubt. I didn't steal it/download it, I made it, but it wasn't my idea, it was his idea. I mean, I think it would be fine if I posted it because, for one, he hasn't posted it on saber font, so he's not selling it, and by posting it on here, I don't plan on making any money out of it XD. It's also not perfect, so, to be honest, if he ever does post his own version, I'll actually buy that XD. So this is my reasoning, but I wanted to ask for opinions first. It was a lot of work to make, but also a lot of fun! I even edited his famous quote to say "I've had it with these motherf.... SITH in this motherf.... plane!". Let's hear your opinions! Thanks! Title: Re: Should I post the "Mace Windu" font I made? Ethical revision, please help Post by: Jediseth on May 16, 2017, 06:03:26 PM I guess you would need to find out if your breaking any rules by posting it. If so I would avoid doing so. Things are getting deleted lately if they aren't in The best interest of the company. My opinion is that's even though it may be funny to you it may not be appropriate.
Title: Re: Should I post the "Mace Windu" font I made? Ethical revision, please help Post by: CyberKyber on May 16, 2017, 06:23:33 PM I guess you would need to find out if your breaking any rules by posting it. If so I would avoid doing so. Things are getting deleted lately if they aren't in The best interest of the company. My opinion is that's even though it may be funny to you it may not be appropriate. Seems like a fair point =/ Title: Re: Should I post the "Mace Windu" font I made? Ethical revision, please help Post by: ModalNodes on May 16, 2017, 08:26:01 PM I agree; the font sounds like it will be cool, but you should definitely check the rules thoroughly before posting it.
Title: Re: Should I post the "Mace Windu" font I made? Ethical revision, please help Post by: Shimmy_Jim on May 16, 2017, 11:07:17 PM It might not have a home here, I think it might be an issue, regardless if you don't mind sharing it with me I would be thrilled to have this on my saber! feel free to personal message me a link to it. It sounds like you put some effort into this and I'd love to check it out! I'm a fan of funny and unique song fonts!
Title: Re: Should I post the "Mace Windu" font I made? Ethical revision, please help Post by: CyberKyber on May 17, 2017, 11:47:12 AM It might not have a home here, I think it might be an issue, regardless if you don't mind sharing it with me I would be thrilled to have this on my saber! feel free to personal message me a link to it. It sounds like you put some effort into this and I'd love to check it out! I'm a fan of funny and unique song fonts! Yeah, sounds like a good idea! If anyone wants the font, just let me know and I'll PM it! I just sent it to you too, Shimmy Jim, hope you enjoy it! And regarding the rules, Rule number 4 is probably the most relevant here: being polite, respectful and courteous. Mentions that colorful language is permitted, but should be a kept to a minimum if possible, and always being respectful to others. However, when it comes to something so specific as creating a sound font that only swears... XD It's too specific, I don't know if it applies here, but for now, if anyone wants it, I'll PM it. Hopefully, eventually someone will be able to clear it up further! Title: Re: Should I post the "Mace Windu" font I made? Ethical revision, please help Post by: ModalNodes on May 17, 2017, 06:10:36 PM CyberKyber, that sounds good! I would love to get the font, so could you please PM that to me, however you do that? Thanks!
Title: Re: Should I post the "Mace Windu" font I made? Ethical revision, please help Post by: CyberKyber on May 17, 2017, 08:03:59 PM CyberKyber, that sounds good! I would love to get the font, so could you please PM that to me, however you do that? Thanks! Donezo! Enjoy! =) Title: Re: Should I post the "Mace Windu" font I made? Ethical revision, please help Post by: projectno253 on May 17, 2017, 11:46:00 PM I guess you would need to find out if your breaking any rules by posting it. If so I would avoid doing so. Things are getting deleted lately if they aren't in The best interest of the company. My opinion is that's even though it may be funny to you it may not be appropriate. What's getting deleted? In response to OP, I see nothing wrong with posting something you made, even if it is from someone else's idea. It was a very broad idea to use someone's voice, so you'd be in your right to do the same. For free of course. Remember that all of this giant business and all of these companies are using an idea from one man, even if some say differently ( yeah, okay) Title: Re: Should I post the "Mace Windu" font I made? Ethical revision, please help Post by: Jediseth on May 17, 2017, 11:54:43 PM What's getting deleted? In response to OP, I see nothing wrong with posting something you made, even if it is from someone else's idea. It was a very broad idea to use someone's voice, so you'd be in your right to do the same. For free of course. Remember that all of this giant business and all of these companies are using an idea from one man, even if some say differently ( yeah, okay) It has nothing to do with it being someone else's idea, but every thing to do with posting a sound font that's profane. Loaded with the F word. Go head and posted it, but don't say I didn't warn you. Title: Re: Should I post the "Mace Windu" font I made? Ethical revision, please help Post by: CyberKyber on May 18, 2017, 10:06:11 AM What's getting deleted? In response to OP, I see nothing wrong with posting something you made, even if it is from someone else's idea. It was a very broad idea to use someone's voice, so you'd be in your right to do the same. For free of course. Remember that all of this giant business and all of these companies are using an idea from one man, even if some say differently ( yeah, okay) That is true XD At the end of the day, it's all Star Wars :P And I get your point. What would be unacceptable, for example, would be to buy a font, convert it, and post it here for people to get for free =S. It has nothing to do with it being someone else's idea, but every thing to do with posting a sound font that's profane. Loaded with the F word. Go head and posted it, but don't say I didn't warn you. Don't worry, I do see your point. As I said before, I'll just PM it to whoever wants it for now. Jediseth, Projectno253, do any of you want it? =) Also, maybe a moderator could give a bit more insight to this? Anyone? :P Title: Re: Should I post the "Mace Windu" font I made? Ethical revision, please help Post by: MARIO9565 on October 30, 2017, 04:17:42 AM i would like this sound font, sounds funny
Title: Re: Should I post the "Mace Windu" font I made? Ethical revision, please help Post by: Zyn on October 30, 2017, 02:02:23 PM I'd love to hear what you came up with. Can you PM me the share address please?
Title: Re: Should I post the "Mace Windu" font I made? Ethical revision, please help Post by: CyberKyber on October 30, 2017, 03:24:36 PM i would like this sound font, sounds funny I'd love to hear what you came up with. Can you PM me the share address please? PMed both of you; enjoy! =) Title: Re: Should I post the "Mace Windu" font I made? Ethical revision, please help Post by: Zyn on October 30, 2017, 03:40:02 PM Those are hysterical! I could actually see SLJ himself using these in a hilarious Star Wars spoof. Well done, and points to you!
Title: Re: Should I post the "Mace Windu" font I made? Ethical revision, please help Post by: CyberKyber on October 30, 2017, 04:08:30 PM Those are hysterical! I could actually see SLJ himself using these in a hilarious Star Wars spoof. Well done, and points to you! Yay, thank you! I honestly wish his fight against Palpatine sounded like that, cursing against the sith all the time XD Title: Re: Should I post the "Mace Windu" font I made? Ethical revision, please help Post by: Zyn on October 30, 2017, 04:13:34 PM Yay, thank you! I honestly wish his fight against Palpatine sounded like that, cursing against the sith all the time XD They couldn't do that because then he would've won the fight and made the original trilogy obsolete. Title: Re: Should I post the "Mace Windu" font I made? Ethical revision, please help Post by: CyberKyber on October 30, 2017, 04:18:19 PM They couldn't do that because then he would've won the fight and made the original trilogy obsolete. +100 Hilarious, Samuel L Jackson breaking the Star Wars universe XD Title: Re: Should I post the "Mace Windu" font I made? Ethical revision, please help Post by: Darth Umbrex on November 01, 2017, 01:43:17 PM I would love to hear this font.
I just want Samuel L Jackson to show up in TLJ with a there's to many mf porgs on this mf falcon. Title: Re: Should I post the "Mace Windu" font I made? Ethical revision, please help Post by: Tzimho on November 02, 2017, 08:44:35 AM Would also love to try this font, getting my Emerald saber this month, so I can start playing with soundfonts.
Title: Re: Should I post the "Mace Windu" font I made? Ethical revision, please help Post by: CyberKyber on November 02, 2017, 10:06:52 AM Would also love to try this font, getting my Emerald saber this month, so I can start playing with soundfonts. I would love to hear this font. I just want Samuel L Jackson to show up in TLJ with a there's to many mf porgs on this mf falcon. PMed both of you with the link, enjoy! And yes, I'd love SML to appear as a force ghost just to drop that line XD Good news for you though, the lockup sound includes a great line: "I've had it with these mother****ing SITH on this mother****ing plane!" Title: Re: Should I post the "Mace Windu" font I made? Ethical revision, please help Post by: BatMike90 on November 03, 2017, 05:10:45 PM Alright, I'll try this font if you don't mind sharing it.
Title: Re: Should I post the "Mace Windu" font I made? Ethical revision, please help Post by: CyberKyber on November 04, 2017, 02:45:19 PM Alright, I'll try this font if you don't mind sharing it. PMed, enjoy! Title: Re: Should I post the "Mace Windu" font I made? Ethical revision, please help Post by: BatMike90 on November 06, 2017, 07:27:52 PM Well that was entertaining! Thanks for the laughs!
Title: Re: Should I post the "Mace Windu" font I made? Ethical revision, please help Post by: JisforJedi on November 07, 2017, 04:00:04 AM Hey, saber just shipped today. I would love to add this font to it. Seems very entertaining. ;D
Title: Re: Should I post the "Mace Windu" font I made? Ethical revision, please help Post by: Master Nero Attoru on November 07, 2017, 12:36:54 PM Here's my position on it, both as a Mod and a longtime member of this community.
As long as you provide the disclaimer regarding profanity, I have no issue with you posting the font itself. It's not immediately visible on the forum, so as long as you warn people it should be fine. As for the ethics angle, I don't see any major problem, but I'd mention Shameem as your inspiration. You didn't take any sounds directly from his font (to my knowledge), so you're not actually using his IP in any way. Give him props, and you should be good. Title: Re: Should I post the "Mace Windu" font I made? Ethical revision, please help Post by: Nabi_333 on November 19, 2017, 02:14:52 AM Hello, there! Would you mind pming me the sound font? Honestly this sounds too good to pass up.
Title: Re: Should I post the "Mace Windu" font I made? Ethical revision, please help Post by: Lady Agana Kath on November 19, 2017, 02:39:26 AM I would also like to give this a try
Title: Re: Should I post the "Mace Windu" font I made? Ethical revision, please help Post by: Randy82103 on November 24, 2017, 02:23:29 PM I'd say that this should be fine!
1) regarding this not being your idea, that's an "old school" way of thinking in that even the US patent office has changed from "first to invent" to "first to file." Anyone can say something, but if you actually did it, that's good for you! 2) regarding the content, it take a lot of effort to put on, so if the file is named appropriately, I can't imagine why that would be banned. Title: Re: Should I post the "Mace Windu" font I made? Ethical revision, please help Post by: EvilOttoJr on December 03, 2017, 11:40:24 PM I'd actually really like to have this font! Nero said above you should be perfectly fine posting it, but if you'd rather not, I'd like a PM for it please!
Title: Re: Should I post the "Mace Windu" font I made? Ethical revision, please help Post by: Dirzanowski on December 24, 2017, 04:41:54 AM PM'ing you, I'd love to have this!
Title: Re: Should I post the "Mace Windu" font I made? Ethical revision, please help Post by: CyberKyber on January 08, 2018, 12:31:33 PM Here's my position on it, both as a Mod and a longtime member of this community. As long as you provide the disclaimer regarding profanity, I have no issue with you posting the font itself. It's not immediately visible on the forum, so as long as you warn people it should be fine. As for the ethics angle, I don't see any major problem, but I'd mention Shameem as your inspiration. You didn't take any sounds directly from his font (to my knowledge), so you're not actually using his IP in any way. Give him props, and you should be good. I'd say that this should be fine! 1) regarding this not being your idea, that's an "old school" way of thinking in that even the US patent office has changed from "first to invent" to "first to file." Anyone can say something, but if you actually did it, that's good for you! 2) regarding the content, it take a lot of effort to put on, so if the file is named appropriately, I can't imagine why that would be banned. Thank you for your input, this has finally convinced me of creating a new thread with the link to the font itself for anyone to download, here it is: http://www.saberforum.com/index.php?topic=37148.0 Now, I've been away from the saber world for some time due to some unforeseen events in my life, but I'm finally back! I'm really sorry for all of you that have PM'ed me about the font and getting back to you so so so late, I have finally PMed you the font. Again, thank you to all of you who have joined the discussion and enjoyed the font! Happy Sabering! And late Merry Christmas! (Yes, that's how long I've been away -_-) |